| Title | Artist | Time | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | West Side Story Medley | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 8:04 | ||
| 2 | As If We Never Said Goodbye | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 5:22 | ||
| 3 | The Prayer | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 4:27 | ||
| 4 | He Lives in You | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 4:41 | ||
| 5 | Evermore | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 3:09 | ||
| 6 | The Rose | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 4:00 | ||
| 7 | Bring Me Sunshine | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 3:54 | ||
| 8 | Some Enchanted Evening | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 3:57 | ||
| 9 | Hero | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 3:18 | ||
| 10 | Not While I'm Around | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 3:47 | ||
| 11 | Stranger in Paradise / And Thi | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 4:38 | ||
| 12 | You're the Voice | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 5:02 | ||
| 13 | New York, New York | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 3:48 | ||
| 14 | You'll Be Back | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 3:31 | ||
| 15 | White Christmas | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 3:05 | ||
| 16 | Once Upon a December | Michael Ball & Alfie Boe | 2:55 |
